india-map

FIND YOUR MP

Switch to Hindi (हिंदी)
  • MPs & MLAs
    Parliament States
  • Legislatures
    Parliament
    Session Track Discussion Papers Parliament Diary Parliament Committees Primer Vital Stats
    States Assembly
    Andhra Pradesh Assam Chhattisgarh Haryana Himachal Pradesh Goa Kerala Madhya Pradesh Maharashtra Punjab Telangana Uttar Pradesh West Bengal
  • Bills & Acts
    Bills Parliament Acts Parliament Bills States State Legislative Briefs Acts States
  • Budgets
    Parliament States Primer
  • Policy
    Analytical Reports Annual Policy Reviews Committee Reports Monthly Policy Reviews President Address Primers Vital Stats COVID-19
  • LAMP
    About the LAMP Fellowship How to Apply Life at LAMP Videos Meet our Fellows Get in touch
  • Careers

FIND YOUR MP

Parliament States
Session Track Discussion Papers Parliament Diary Parliament Committees Primer Vital Stats
Andhra Pradesh Chhattisgarh Haryana Himachal Pradesh Goa Madhya Pradesh Maharashtra Telangana Uttar Pradesh
Bills Parliament Acts Parliament Bills States State Legislative briefs Acts States
Parliament States Primer
Analytical Reports Annual Policy Reviews Committee Reports Monthly Policy Reviews President Address Primers Vital Stats COVID-19
About the LAMP Fellowship How to Apply Life at LAMP Videos Meet our Fellows Get in touch
  • Articles by PRS Team
  • bricks-and-mortar-as-well

Archives

2022
  • May, 2022
  • April, 2022
  • March, 2022
  • February, 2022
  • January, 2022
2021
  • December, 2021
  • November, 2021
  • October, 2021
  • September, 2021
  • August, 2021
  • July, 2021
  • June, 2021
  • May, 2021
  • April, 2021
  • March, 2021
  • February, 2021
  • January, 2021
2020
  • December, 2020
  • October, 2020
  • September, 2020
  • August, 2020
  • July, 2020
  • June, 2020
  • May, 2020
  • April, 2020
  • March, 2020
  • January, 2020
2019
  • December, 2019
  • November, 2019
  • October, 2019
  • September, 2019
  • August, 2019
  • July, 2019
  • June, 2019
  • May, 2019
  • February, 2019
  • January, 2019
2018
  • December, 2018
  • October, 2018
  • September, 2018
  • August, 2018
  • July, 2018
  • May, 2018
  • April, 2018
  • January, 2018
2017
  • December, 2017
  • May, 2017
  • March, 2017
  • February, 2017
  • January, 2017
2016
  • December, 2016
  • August, 2016
  • March, 2016
2015
  • April, 2015
  • February, 2015
2014
  • December, 2014
  • November, 2014
  • August, 2014
  • June, 2014
  • May, 2014
  • April, 2014
  • March, 2014
  • February, 2014
  • January, 2014
2013
  • December, 2013
  • November, 2013
  • October, 2013
  • September, 2013
  • August, 2013
  • July, 2013
  • June, 2013
  • May, 2013
  • April, 2013
  • March, 2013
  • February, 2013
2012
  • December, 2012
  • November, 2012
  • August, 2012
  • May, 2012
  • April, 2012
  • March, 2012
  • February, 2012
  • January, 2012
2011
  • December, 2011
  • November, 2011
  • September, 2011
  • August, 2011
  • July, 2011
  • June, 2011
  • May, 2011
  • April, 2011
  • March, 2011
  • February, 2011
  • January, 2011
2010
  • December, 2010
  • November, 2010
  • October, 2010
  • September, 2010
  • August, 2010
  • July, 2010
  • June, 2010
  • May, 2010
  • April, 2010
  • March, 2010
  • February, 2010
  • January, 2010
2009
  • December, 2009
  • November, 2009
  • October, 2009
  • April, 2009

Bricks And Mortar As Well


Chakshu RoyIndian Express, Aug 8, 2016

Last week newspapers reported that the government is agreeable to the idea of a new parliament building. For some time, the idea behind a new parliament building has been gaining momentum. Last year Speaker Sumitra Mahajan wrote to the urban development ministry stating that the iconic circular building was showing “signs of distress”. In 2012 Meira Kumar, the then Lok Sabha speaker, said that the parliament building is “weeping”.

Some experts point out the inadequacy of office space for political parties in the building. They also refer to major and minor incidents which are a cause of concern. A fire in the parliament house complex, earlier this year, and the disruptions of Rajya Sabha proceedings in 2012 due to a stench in the house being two of them. Other experts believe that with proper restoration and upkeep, the parliament building can continue to function for many more years. In this debate, we overlook that there is more to the institution of parliament than the building it is housed in. Equally, if not more important, than the circular edifice of parliament are the rules of procedure that govern its functioning. The last major procedural change was in the early 1990s when the standing committee system was introduced.Our constitution empowers both houses of parliament to make their own procedures. The two houses have their own rule book which guides their functioning. Therefore the rules applicable in the two houses while being broadly similar differ on some aspects. For example, Rajya Sabha MPs are required to declare their financial interests in a register maintained by their committee of ethics. However, Lok Sabha MPs do not have a similar requirement. The houses can change their procedures based on the recommendation of the rules committee of their house. The rules committee of Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha have produced a total of 14 reports in the past 15 years recommending changes in the functioning of the two houses.

Our constitution empowers both houses of parliament to make their own procedures. The two houses have their own rule book which guides their functioning. Therefore the rules applicable in the two houses while being broadly similar differ on some aspects. For example, Rajya Sabha MPs are required to declare their financial interests in a register maintained by their committee of ethics. However, Lok Sabha MPs do not have a similar requirement. The houses can change their procedures based on the recommendation of the rules committee of their house. The rules committee of Lok Sabha and Rajya Sabha have produced a total of 14 reports in the past 15 years recommending changes in the functioning of the two houses.

Some of these improvements can help streamline parliamentary functioning. For example, currently all bills are not referred to standing committees for scrutiny. When the government wants to push certain legislation through parliament quickly it can request the presiding officer of a house to not refer the bill to a committee. While this ensures quick passage of legislation it also means that parliamentary scrutiny is compromised. Changing the rules of procedure making it mandatory for all bills to be examined by committees will strengthen parliament’s law making ability. Similarly, at times, the government tries to introduce, discuss and pass a bill on the same day. Suspension of certain procedures in the rule book gives the government the ability to do so. Mandating that bills can only be passed after members of the house have been given a reasonable time to study the bills will ensure that MPs are able to contribute effectively to legislative discussions.

Parliamentary procedure has been reformed and updated in many countries. In the UK a committee on modernisation of the House of Commons was established in 1997 Based on its recommendations, programming of legislation and more scrutiny of legislative proposals have started taking place in the UK parliament. Another important change based on this committee’s recommendation was advance planning of the parliamentary calendar. Overhauling parliamentary procedure will also have a cascading effect on state legislatures. A new building of parliament will have no meaning, if the procedures of parliament are also not modernised.

Overhauling parliamentary procedure will also have a cascading effect on state legislatures. A new building of parliament will have no meaning, if the procedures of parliament are also not modernised.

Follow Us

Creative Commons License

PRS Legislative Research is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Disclaimer: This data is being furnished to you for your information. PRS makes every effort to use reliable and comprehensive information, but PRS does not represent that this information is accurate or complete. PRS is an independent, not-for-profit group. This data has been collated without regard to the objectives or opinions of those who may receive it.

  • About Us
  • Careers
Copyright © 2022    prsindia.org    All Rights Reserved.