india-map

FIND YOUR MP

Switch to Hindi (हिंदी)
  • MPs & MLAs
    Parliament States
  • Legislatures
    Parliament
    Session Track Parliament Diary Parliament Committees Primer Vital Stats
    States
    Legislature Track Vital Stats
    Discussion Papers
  • Bills & Acts
    Bills Parliament Acts Parliament Bills States State Legislative Briefs Acts States
  • Budgets
    Parliament States Discussion Papers
  • Policy
    Discussion Papers Science & Technology Policy Monthly Policy Reviews Annual Policy Reviews Committee Reports President Address Vital Stats COVID-19
  • LAMP
    About the LAMP Fellowship How to Apply Life at LAMP Videos Meet our Fellows Get in touch
  • Careers

FIND YOUR MP

Parliament States
Session Track Parliament Diary Parliament Committees Primer Vital Stats
Legislature Track Vital Stats
Discussion Papers
Bills Parliament Acts Parliament Bills States State Legislative briefs Acts States
Parliament States Discussion Papers
Discussion Papers Science & Technology Policy Monthly Policy Reviews Annual Policy Reviews Committee Reports President Address Vital Stats COVID-19
About the LAMP Fellowship How to Apply Life at LAMP Videos Meet our Fellows Get in touch
  • Articles by PRS Team
  • how-rajya-sabha-polls-came-to-be-open-ballot

Archives

2023
  • January, 2023
2022
  • December, 2022
  • November, 2022
  • October, 2022
  • September, 2022
  • August, 2022
  • July, 2022
  • June, 2022
  • May, 2022
  • April, 2022
  • March, 2022
  • February, 2022
  • January, 2022
2021
  • December, 2021
  • November, 2021
  • October, 2021
  • September, 2021
  • August, 2021
  • July, 2021
  • June, 2021
  • May, 2021
  • April, 2021
  • March, 2021
  • February, 2021
  • January, 2021
2020
  • December, 2020
  • October, 2020
  • September, 2020
  • August, 2020
  • July, 2020
  • June, 2020
  • May, 2020
  • April, 2020
  • March, 2020
  • January, 2020
2019
  • December, 2019
  • November, 2019
  • October, 2019
  • September, 2019
  • August, 2019
  • July, 2019
  • June, 2019
  • May, 2019
  • February, 2019
  • January, 2019
2018
  • December, 2018
  • October, 2018
  • September, 2018
  • August, 2018
  • July, 2018
  • May, 2018
  • April, 2018
  • January, 2018
2017
  • December, 2017
  • May, 2017
  • March, 2017
  • February, 2017
  • January, 2017
2016
  • December, 2016
  • August, 2016
  • March, 2016
2015
  • April, 2015
  • February, 2015
2014
  • December, 2014
  • November, 2014
  • August, 2014
  • June, 2014
  • May, 2014
  • April, 2014
  • March, 2014
  • February, 2014
  • January, 2014
2013
  • December, 2013
  • November, 2013
  • October, 2013
  • September, 2013
  • August, 2013
  • July, 2013
  • June, 2013
  • May, 2013
  • April, 2013
  • March, 2013
  • February, 2013
2012
  • December, 2012
  • November, 2012
  • August, 2012
  • May, 2012
  • April, 2012
  • March, 2012
  • February, 2012
  • January, 2012
2011
  • December, 2011
  • November, 2011
  • September, 2011
  • August, 2011
  • July, 2011
  • June, 2011
  • May, 2011
  • April, 2011
  • March, 2011
  • February, 2011
  • January, 2011
2010
  • December, 2010
  • November, 2010
  • October, 2010
  • September, 2010
  • August, 2010
  • July, 2010
  • June, 2010
  • May, 2010
  • April, 2010
  • March, 2010
  • February, 2010
  • January, 2010
2009
  • December, 2009
  • November, 2009
  • October, 2009
  • April, 2009

How Rajya Sabha polls came to be open ballot


Chakshu Roy, Indian Express, June 3, 2022

The foundation of free and fair elections is the secrecy of the ballot. The Rajya Sabha elections are unique in that respect, where voting is not secret. The MLAs elect their state Rajya Sabha MPs, and as the process stands now, have to show the votes to their party’s representative. However, the open ballot voting system is a 2003 addition to our Rajya Sabha electoral system.

Until 1998, Rajya Sabha elections were the bastion of party discipline, their outcome a foregone conclusion. Candidates nominated by parties would win uncontested. Voting only took place when there were more contestants than vacant seats in the state. Electoral contest was usually among Independent candidates.

The June 1998 Rajya Sabha elections in Maharashtra changed this position. Seven contenders were in the fray for six seats. The Congress had fielded two candidates — Najma Heptullah, who had served three terms in the Upper House, and Ram Pradhan, a former Maharashtra-cadre IAS officer and ex-Union home secretary. The Shiv Sena’s candidates were its sitting MP Satish Pradhan and media personality Pritish Nandy. Pramod Mahajan, who had lost the Lok Sabha elections earlier that year, was contesting for the BJP.

There were two Independent candidates: media baron Vijay Darda, whom the Congress supported, and former railway minister Suresh Kalmadi, whom the Shiv Sena supported. Kalmadi had rebelled against the Congress.

The Congress had enough votes to ensure the victory of both its candidates. But in a surprising turn of events, Congress candidate Ram Pradhan, a close aide of Sonia Gandhi, lost. An Independent candidate sailed through.
The votes cast by MLAs were secret, and Congress MLAs defied their party’s voting instructions, causing Pradhan’s defeat. Reports suggest that legislators from other parties also cross-voted.

Pradhan’s loss reverberated in all political circles to a point that parties started thinking about steps to rein in their MLAs.

The solution eventually came from the Ethics Committee of the Rajya Sabha, which was set up in 1997 and was headed by Rajya Sabha MP and former Maharashtra Chief Minister S B Chavan.

In its first report in December 1998, the committee observed that money and muscle power played an increasing role in Rajya Sabha elections, suggesting: “In order not to allow big money and other considerations to play mischief… the Committee is of the view that instead of a secret ballot, the question of holding the elections to the Rajya Sabha and the Legislative Councils in states by open ballot may be examined.”

The Atal Bihari Vajpayee government in 2001 acted on the suggestion.

Arun Jaitley, the law minister at the time, introduced a Bill in Parliament to amend the law relating to the Rajya Sabha elections with an open voting system and the removal of domiciliary requirements for contesting the polls. Kuldeep Nayar, a veteran journalist who was a nominated Rajya Sabha MP, challenged its constitutional validity in the Supreme Court, arguing that the “concept of open ballot would defeat the attainment of free and fair elections”.

The Court overruled this contention and held the law to be constitutional. It reasoned that “the secrecy of the ballot is a vital principle for ensuring free and fair elections. The higher principle, however, is free and fair elections and purity of elections. If secrecy becomes a source for corruption, then sunlight and transparency have the capacity to remove it”.

But an open ballot has not helped bring purity to the Rajya Sabha elections or stopped party candidates from losing. A common response of the parties, as evident in the recent Rajya Sabha elections, has been to herd their MLAs to hotels and resorts to prevent poaching.

As Niloptal Basu, a CPM Rajya Sabha MP, said during the debate on the open ballot law: “We should, as political parties, seriously introspect as to how the principles on which political parties function can be rectified; as to how we can recapture certain healthy practices in politics…The problem of indiscipline and the problem of dissidents can never be stopped in this manner unless we improve our system of internal democracy, unless we have healthy practices”.

The writer is head of outreach PRS Legislative Research

Follow Us

Creative Commons License

PRS Legislative Research is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License

Disclaimer: This data is being furnished to you for your information. PRS makes every effort to use reliable and comprehensive information, but PRS does not represent that this information is accurate or complete. PRS is an independent, not-for-profit group. This data has been collated without regard to the objectives or opinions of those who may receive it.

  • About Us
  • Careers
Copyright © 2023    prsindia.org    All Rights Reserved.